UCI Band: Commentary - 11/22/98
Trouble is Brewing

Robert C. Carden IV

It's almost Thanksgiving and about this time, we have a good idea on how the band is going to be for the rest of this season.  For some mysterious reason, our numbers have dwindled (like they always do), and this year, we seem to have taken most of the hit in the trumpet section.  I knew it was too good to be true.  I guess having 17 trumpets on the rolls was just too much for this group.

At the California All Stars game, we started the pregame with only two trumpets.   Another one showed up midway through, but it was a bit shocking to see such a large section so small in numbers.  Yesterday, at the women's game against Syracuse, we had only four trumpets, a far cry from 8-12 that we had at Midnight Magic.  This concerned Mike so much (and I am theorizing here) that he had an open discussion last Monday to try to see what, if anything, is ticking us off.  One of the things that seems to have happened is that a number of trumpets who showed up regularly last year because they felt they were desperately needed (and they were, too), don't feel that way anymore.

I don't really know what, if anything, Mike can do to make things any better.   Maybe the schedule is just too much for a lot of people.  Maybe, once they discovered other, less demanding groups like the Wind Ensemble, they decided this was not for them.  Maybe we're just advertising to the wrong group of people.  Maybe there just aren't enough basketball fans who also play musical instruments.  Maybe that will all improve as the team improves.

On the topic of CD music versus live music...

Last night, as we waited for our pizza to arrive, a number of band members expressed concern and disdain for the athletic department's practice of playing taped (CD) music when the band could be playing live.  These same members said that we definitely do not play enough.  I decided to write a definitive statement about what I think we as a band should be doing.

  1. Taped music (commonly called canned music) should be kept to a minimum.
  2. As we get to the end of the game, particularly when it is close, the Band should be allowed to play at all timeouts.  The director of the Band should be the one to call for taped music, if any.
  3. The current policy of playing a CD if we win and the Fight Song if we lose is completely for the birds.  In fact, it is just the opposite of what we should do.   Playing the Fight Song after a loss makes us sound like we are celebrating our loss.  That is exactly the wrong signal to send and we must cease and desist such a practice.  However, it is not up to Mike, our director.  The Athletic department has ordered us to follow this abhorrent practice.
  4. The Band should play the Star Spangled Banner at all games.  If the director fears that we may not have enough band members available for a given game, he will notify the Athletic department in advance to arrange for a singer.
  5. The Band should have a number of quick charts to memorized, ready to play, at a moments notice.  The sections themselves need to be able to kick it off with the rest of the band joining in.  For instance, trumpets should kick of some of the charges.   A drum hit can kick of something else.  Spontaneity is the key.  An example of this which we do today is when an opposing player fouls out, I kick off a round of Na-Na-Na-Na-Goodbye and the rest of the band joins in.  It is important for one person (or group of people) to assume responsibility.

Those are my opinions and I must admit that I don't expect us to get there immediately.  However, I want it noted what I think we should do.

Related commentaries

December 1, 1997 - 1. Background - making a stand.   We had a band, a decent band, at the 11/23 Women's basketball game. We were ready to play 30 minutes before the start of the game. So what happened? We waited and waited and waited while athletics played their canned music to an almost empty Bren Center. Once the game started...

December 21, 1997 - The Orange County Register really has it in for the UCI men's basketball team. Janis Carr, the sports writer assigned to UCI, wrote the following in his pregame prospectus.  The Anteaters are looking for their first victory against a Division I team, and it is doubtful it will come against the Pilots. Portland is coming off a 79-64 victory...


Commentary List - Previous Commentary - Next Commentary


Previous Page - Next Page


[ Home | UCI Band | UCI Basketball | UCI Band History ]

Robert C. Carden IV.
Copyright © 1998-2006 Wonder Mountain. All rights reserved.
Revised: November 24, 2006.